The DISH

Unbossed and unbought news and information you can use

Vol. 14 No. 13…Dedicated to the Dialogue on Race…March 28, 2011

 

 

Georgia Students Losing HOPE

By John Burl Smith



The new Tea Party/Republican wave is making itself felt in ways that most Americans who were caught up in its rhetoric did not imagine. Most notably, its blatant attack on social services, collective bargaining and public sector employees all under the guise of deficit reduction has caused "buyer's remorse" among many voters. These voters now see that the "devil is in the details." Along with minorities -- blacks, Hispanics and other immigrants -- their lives are also falling under the ax. Frightening for most are the cuts in education that threaten to segregate students along class rather than racial lines and slam shut the door on hopes for middle class lifestyles.

 

This new segregation will not tax just blacks to funnel money to educate rich white children; it will rob everyone below a certain economic level. Under the radar, many public educational assistance programs such as the Academic Competitiveness Grant and the SMART Grant programs that white students have relied on for years are set to expire by July, and at the state level, such funding is being slashed drastically if not eliminated altogether.

 

The State of Georgia is a microcosm of this national trend of cuts in educational assistance that will dramatically impact students from lower income families. Republican Governor Nathan Deal did not mention redesigning HOPE Scholarships during his campaign. HOPE was originally designed as a "sugar pill" to gain black voters' support for the Georgia Lottery by providing need-based assistance for children of working class families to attend college. Subsequently, it has been expanded to include all Georgia's children. The lottery also funds the Pre-K program for children 4 years old.

 

Equalizing educational opportunities is no longer a goal, now that Republicans run the state. Limiting access and competition for space in Georgia colleges and universities to students from lower income families is the aim of Deal's makeover of HOPE. Pitched as "closing a $300 million shortfall" that will "pull HOPE and Georgia Pre-K from the brink of bankruptcy," his solution is like Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker's attack on public employees bargaining rights to solve that state's budget problem. They both designed a solution that targets particular populations to justify their real motives.


Democrats used press conferences in downtrodden, inner city Atlanta neighborhoods, such as Vine City, where one of the top-selling retailers for lottery tickets is located, to emphasize what should be the guiding principles for HOPE. Minority Senate Leader Robert Brown (D-Macon) told reporters that "customers from low-income neighborhoods purchase the bulk of lottery tickets in Georgia. State Sen. Emanuel Jones (D-Decatur) called Deal's scheme a "redistribution of wealth from the poor to the wealthy," because it does not consider need, only grade point average (GPA) and SAT scores.


Democrats are concerned that changes to HOPE will disproportionately affect families already struggling under other budget cuts, high unemployment and reduced incomes in a sluggish economy. HOPE changes tie the amount of scholarships to lottery revenues instead of tuition cost. Next year, a HOPE scholarship will cover only 90 percent of tuition costs; however as tuition costs are increasing, the scholarship will cover smaller and smaller proportion of tuition, which will not affect the ability of children of wealthy parents to attend school.


State Sen. Jim Butterworth (R-Cornelia), Chairman of the Senate Higher Education Committee claims, "The cuts are a shared burden because it reduces benefits for students regardless of their income level." However, many testifying in opposition to HOPE changes pointed out that students of wealthy parents receiving HOPE scholarships at the University of Georgia, Athens, drive fancy cars, live in "mini-mansions and enjoy luxurious lifestyles because they do not depend on HOPE money to attend school.


Compounding the problem for low income students, the U. S. House budget will slash Pell Grants by almost 15%, reducing the maximum award to $4,705 from $5,550. President Obama plans to eliminate summer Pell Grants and end loan interest subsidies for graduate students.

 

HOPE changes also favor wealthy students in regards to its merit-based criteria by adding the requirement of a 1200 SAT score to receive 100 percent of tuition from HOPE. High SAT scores tend to penalize poor students who cannot afford special SAT classes as wealthy students, whose scores are higher as a group. This gives added weight to Democrat charges that HOPE changes amount to a wealth transfer.


Amidst protests, inside and outside the legislature, Republicans still steam-rolled a HOPE reform package that placed the greatest burden of reform on students rather than spreading the "shared burden" of reduced benefits to the Georgia Lottery Corporation by mandating that it put more money into the educational fund and incentivizing employee bonuses - ideas Deal rejected. The Corporation currently only pays 24 percent of lottery proceeds into the educational fund annually, which is well below the national average of 29 percent.

 

During committee hearing, Sen. Nan Orrock (D-Atlanta) addressed the "big gap" between the Georgia Lottery Corporation educational funding and the national average. "We've been aghast at the bonuses the Georgia Lottery executives give themselves. According to www.atlantaunfiltered.com Lottery Corporation CEO Margaret Defrancisco made $496,776 - including a bonus of $143,276 in 2010. Republicans rejected a Democrat amendment that would have required at least 30 percent of lottery proceeds go to education by 2015."

 

Changes in HOPE scholarships will have the largest impact on future college students. High school students will now be required to have a 3.7 GPA and a 1200 SAT score in order to become Zell Miller Scholars and earn a full tuition scholarship. A full tuition scholarship is also available for every valedictorian and salutatorian in the state. Currently, students need only a 3.0 GPA to receive HOPE scholarships, but reforms raise that to a 3.3 GPA.

 

 

Southwest DeKalb Losing Out on School Closings



No matter the nature of the need to reduce government spending, Southwest DeKalb County, Georgia citizens have found their services on the chopping block. They have suffered the brunt of cost cutting that benefit other areas going back to the 1970s, when black home buyers were steered to communities like Gresham Park and East Atlanta. White families moved North or East to escape integration and economic development followed, dodging "redlined" areas. Over the past fifty years there has been a continual transfer of wealth out of Southwest to North and East DeKalb County. This pattern has never been more evident than now under the current economic recession.

 

On March 7, 2011, the DeKalb County School Board voted to close eight schools to avert a projected shortfall, only one school in North DeKalb County will be closed. The school closings will redistrict 6,000 to 7,000 mostly Southwest DeKalb students to save about $12.4 million a year, School Board Chairman Thomas Bowen claimed. Bowen sees the closings and consolidation only in economic terms not to improve educational quality. "We're closing the buildings because it's inefficient for us. What we want is the savings, the $12.4 million."


District 7 Board member Donna Edler fought to keep some of the proposed schools open. Edler emphasized that more open discussion was needed between board members and said, "I was disappointed the board was unable to meet as a whole to discuss the plan before the vote. This is the only opportunity that the board [has had] to discuss this plan as a [whole], I didn't think it was sufficient. To govern effectively, I think we need to be deliberative and debate as a board, but I think it was a foregone conclusion."

 

Edler expressed concerns that all of the schools slated to close did not meet the requirements in the plan, specifically, that of the student criteria and number of seats utilized. "Glen Haven Elementary school is currently at 82 percent capacity with 454 students as stated in the [interim] superintendent's recommendation. That is over the 450 student criteria for closing as well as the 82 percent being above the utilization. I do not see why Glen Haven is on the list for closing."

 

Schools on the North end such as Medlock, which fell within the closing criteria, received differential consideration. Flat Rock and Bouie Elementary Schools will not close, after a decision to make Flat Rock Elementary a theme school and Bouie Theme School into a neighborhood school. The board also decided to keep Dunwoody and other North DeKalb areas high schools off the chopping block.


A hearing on a lawsuit filed by South DeKalb parents seeking an injunction to stop implementation of the redistricting plan before Judge Michael Hancock has not been scheduled; the NAACP is also poised to join the suit. The injunction seeks to address the "threads of segregation and gentrification" implied by the Board's action. Parents say, "We want an audit of the entire system because we want to know the numbers, the finances, and how the district equalizes spending of funds."

 

Referring to the suit DeKalb NAACP chapter's president Yvonne Hawks said, "The school closings will devastate neighborhoods. You'll have more abandoned buildings which will increase vandalism, decrease new homeownership and negatively affect local businesses."

 

County government should be exploring ways to increase the viability of the Southwest part of the county, rather than undercutting its shrinking tax base. The North and East portions of the county are already thriving with economic development, while the Southwest is being neglected; nothing is being done to bring jobs into the area.



Southwest DeKalb Could Lose Library



As the slow inexorable devastation of Southwest DeKalb continues, the DeKalb Library Board of trustees voted March 9 to close the Scott-Candler Library after 47 years. This decision came on the heels of other budget cuts of which Southwest DeKalb has borne the brunt. These cuts, including slashing the number of buses and routes serving South DeKalb by the Metro Atlanta Regional Transportation Authority (MARTA) and the DeKalb School Board's closure of seven area elementary schools, demonstrate grave disparities in service and a lack of equity in spending DeKalb County tax revenue.

 

In addition to voting to close the Scott-Candler Library, the trustees voted to eliminate Sunday openings, cut Friday and Saturday hours at four branches, and cut night hours one day a week at all branches in response to a 22% budget decrease. Alison Weissinger, acting director, said system cutbacks are countywide but only the Scott-Candler branch will be closed. Board of trustees Chair Deborah Torbush said, "The system's 2011 budget of $12.4 million is $3 million short."

 

Rather than maintain current branches, Weissinger said, "The board decided to push ahead with a $16.6 million expansion, even though the system's operational budget has remained flat, since voters approved the $230 million bond referendum in 2005. Now the system is 2/3 of the way through the expansion, but we don't have the people to staff these libraries. This year, the system has 60 to 65 vacant positions that are authorized but not funded."


According to Weissinger, "The top priority is to open three new and expanded branches-- Stonecrest $7.7 million, Salem-Panola $4.5 million and Hairston Crossing $4.4 (all in East DeKalb) --beginning April 16. These branches have been sitting closed for months for want of staff to operate them. Closing the Scott-Candler branch April 1 will allow us to transfer the staff to these branches."


Protests by area residents and a petition with 100 signatures collected by 12-year-old Sekondi Landry have forced the library board of trustees to temporarily rescind its decision to close Scott-Candler. The board of trustees will revisit its decision to close the library on June 30. In the interim, the library will maintain a limited schedule. It will be open Monday and Tuesday 11 a.m. - 8 p.m. and 11 a.m. - 5 p.m. Wednesday and Thursday.


Should the library eventually be closed, families in the low income area around it will go without access to books and computers.



South DeKalb Loses Again on Health Care



The battle for affordable health care continues on the national level but by this summer, residents around Candler Road who use the Grady South DeKalb Health Center will have to travel an extra 5.4 miles to get care. Grady Health System will close the South DeKalb Health Center after 15 years, although it had 6,500 patient visits, up from 6,000 in 2008 and is Grady's only center in DeKalb County south of Memorial Drive, as part of a $30 million cost-cutting measure. This is the second time in less than two years that Michael Young CEO of Grady Memorial Hospital Corp., has targeted the center for closing.


He backed away from closing the center in 2009 after the DeKalb Board of Commissioners threatened to cut the county's annual funding for Grady Hospital. Even though Grady is the metro area's safety-net hospital and provides indigent care for residents of counties in the surrounding area, DeKalb and Fulton are the only two metro Atlanta counties that fund Grady. DeKalb shaved $3.4 million from its annual contribution of $15.7 million. DeKalb Commissioner Larry Johnson, who represents the area, said he is sure Grady will blame the closing on reduced funding.

 

Fulton also reduced it funding to $52.2 million from $85.8 million. The hospital said its federal funding has also fallen to $64.5 million from a high of $101.5 million four years ago. Over the same period, it said, its indigent care cost went to $222.2 million from $180.9 million. Starting April 4, Grady will begin charging a co-pay of $2 to $3, and homeless patients will now be required to pay $1 per prescription. It estimates that it will raise $6 million from the new co-pays. It also is cutting 100 non-medical staff positions.

 

Commissioner Johnson, the presiding officer of the DeKalb Commission said, "I asked Young for information and analysis to support the decision to close the center but he's not provided it." Johnson said Grady has not been able to tell him how much of the funding provided by the county goes to running its South DeKalb Health Center. "We give them one pot of money and they can't show me the numbers. I want them to share with me the cost of running that center."

 

He said of DeKalb's 30-year agreement to fund Grady which expires in 2013, "This time as we negotiate a new agreement they will have to be specific about where the money given by the county will be spent. It won't be as vague as this one." Southwest DeKalb residents now see how decisions that drain tax revenues, economic development and jobs from communities by government commissions, boards and agencies turn "middle class" neighborhoods into dilapidated ghettos.





News You Use

Debt, Austerity and How to Fight Back

By Frances Fox Piven and Cornel West



Wall Street Banks, American corporations and their political allies have declared a one-sided war on the American people. This war is being waged at our schools and colleges, the workplace and in our communities.

 

Today, Americans are working harder and earning less while corporate profits soar. As homeowners, consumers and students we see our wealth being stripped away by banks. Our government plunges into debt waging trillion-dollar wars. Meanwhile, our infrastructure erodes and climate change proceeds unchecked. Schools, daycare centers, senior citizen facilities, clinics, parks and firehouses are starved for funds so that corporations and the rich can get billions in tax breaks!

 

Corporate America's unprovoked assault on working people has been carried out by manufacturing a need for fiscal austerity. We are told that there is no more money for essential human services, for the care of children, or better public schools, or to help lower the cost of a college education. The fact is that big banks and large corporations are hoarding trillions in cash and using tax loopholes to bankrupt our communities.


Spending on social needs is not the reason governments at all levels are facing massive budget short falls. Our debt and deficit problems are a direct result of corporate tax rollbacks, and the extortionist policies of banks and financial institutions that are engaged in a coordinated and massive wealth transfer from the American people to their own coffers.

 

The courageous actions by the citizens in Wisconsin are an inspiring defense of the core values of this country: a civil society based on freedom of association, ensuring that our communities have high quality public services-education, public safety and support for our elderly and most vulnerable-along with good jobs for all. The outpouring of support nationally shows the possibilities for challenging deepening economic inequality and political marginalization of the majority of the American people.

 

We are on the cusp of a great movement to resist and roll back that corporate domination by banks, energy companies and war profiteers. To join that movement and escalate the activism planned in the days, weeks and months ahead we are organizing a "National Teach-in on Debt, Austerity and How People Are Fighting Back." The live web-streamed teach-in will be held on Tuesday, April 5, 2011, at the Judson Memorial Church in New York City, beginning at 2 pm (EST). Admission is free.

 

Speakers from schools and communities around the country will be hosted by moderators Frances Fox Piven and Cornel West in New York City through a live webcast that you can join by organizing a teach-in on your own campus. For ideas on how you can participate and technical assistance on connecting to the live webcast from New York City, please see www.fightbackteachin.org.





Hood Notes

Boosting College Graduation Rate



Recently, Vice President Joe Biden unveiled an administration plan to involve governors directly in efforts to boost college graduation rates as part of President Barack Obama's goal for the US to achieve the world's highest college graduation rate by 2020. According to a study published last year by the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development, Korea has the best college graduation rate; 58 percent of its population ages 25-34 has finished college; the U.S. is ranked ninth at 42 percent.


The Education Department projects the nation will need to increase its graduation rate by 50 percent by the end of the decade to gain the top spot. Graduation rates among the states range from a low of 28 percent in Arkansas, Nevada and New Mexico to 54 percent in Massachusetts. The District of Columbia has the highest rate; 65 percent of its residents hold degrees.

 

The Education Department has announced $20 million in grants for innovations designed to improve success and productivity at post-secondary schools. The administration has proposed another $123 million in competitive funds for programs that speed learning, boost graduation rates and hold down tuition. A second proposed program of $50 million would reward states and institutions for producing more college grads.

 

To improve college graduation rates, states must significantly raise high school graduation rates and better prepare students for college-level courses. In addition, Robert Schwartz, academic dean at the Harvard Graduate School of Education, has cautioned that achieving a 60 percent national graduation rate will not be a panacea. His Pathways to Prosperity Project, which released a study in February, has concluded that the US education system should offer greater emphasis on occupational instruction. According to Schwartz, "What's the strategy for the other 40 percent of people? We can't keep saying, 'College for all, college for all' and yet set targets that even if you could meet them are going to leave out very large proportions of young people."  Moreover, it does not guarantee jobs for those that do graduate.






Politics Y2K11

Republican Hopefuls Criticize Public Schools

By Kay Henderson



Three potential 2012 Republican presidential candidates expressed hostility toward the public school system at a home schooling rally on Wednesday in the early presidential caucus state of Iowa.

 

Texas Congressman Ron Paul told the crowd government wants "absolute control" of the "indoctrination" of children. Paul spoke along with Minnesota Congresswoman Michele Bachmann and Georgia businessman Herman Cain.

 

"The public school system now is a propaganda machine," Paul said, prompting applause from the crowd of hundreds of home schooling families. "They start with our kids even in kindergarten, teaching them about family values, sexual education, gun rights, environmentalism - and they condition them to believe in so much which is totally un-American."

 

Bachmann claimed home schooling is the "essence" of freedom and liberty. Bachmann, who home-schooled her five biological children, lamented that she and her husband had been unable to teach the 23 foster children who have lived in their home because Minnesota authorities said foster children could not be home-schooled. "It is not up to a bureaucrat to decide what is best for your children," she said, drawing cheers from the crowd. "I am so tired of the establishment telling us that they know best. We know best."

Cain, former chief executive of Godfather's Pizza and another prospective Republican candidate, denounced government involvement in education at all levels. "That's all we want is for government to get out of the way so we can educate ourselves and our children the old-fashioned way," Cain said.

 

Justin LaVan of the Network of Iowa Christian Home Educators said it was encouraging to see potential presidential candidates talk about the home-schooling movement. (Source: http://news.yahoo.com/s/nm/20110323/pl_nm/us_iowa)





Disgruntled feels: Baffled! For half a century, I have watched as hundreds of thousands of Africans died of hunger, curable diseases and thirst, as well as millions killed in civil conflicts across that vast continent. Not once over that period has the West, including the US, embarked on a humanitarian campaign to halt the slaughter of the innocent on the order of a "war on terror" or even the recently implemented no-fly zone over Libya to prevent a 'possible' massacre of Libyans by Col. Moammar Gadhafi. Even as the US government faces record deficits with calls by members of Congress to cut spending on every social welfare program from education to WIC, it can afford to spend hundreds of millions of dollars on more warfare. To say that I am baffled by the reasons offered for this incursion into Libya would be an understatement, since the dictators supported by the West are also killing peaceful protestors and no UN resolution is being sought to impose penalties and authorize punitive measures against those countries to halt their actions. It makes one wonder about the real motives of the West in attacking Libya.



Disgruntled says: There is a glaring double standard in media coverage of events in the Palestinian territories and Israel. For example, on Tuesday, several Israeli tank shells landed on a playground in Gaza City, killing three children and their grandfather and injuring 12 other children and women. The Israeli army confirmed the shelling and apologized for killing civilians; the attack apparently came in response to a round of mortar shells aimed by Hamas at an illegal settlement less than half a mile from the playground. There was no report of anyone killed or injured by the mortar round. On CNN coverage of the incident in Gaza City was relegated to the scroll bar. A few days later, a bomb exploded on a bus in Jerusalem, killing one woman and injuring others. It was the first such attack in four years. CNN's Wolf Blitzer interviewed the mayor of Jerusalem.



Disgruntled wants to know: I have spent a considerable amount of time trying to figure out what makes Democrats and Republicans see President Barack Obama differently from George W. Bush when it comes to warfare. When Obama went to Afghanistan and gave a speech about US military involvement in that country, he sounded just like Bush; his whole war on terror spill was a page directly out of Bush's neo-con foreign policy playbook. Quite frankly, I am hard pressed to discern any divergence from that Bush doctrine. Obama's war on Libya just confirms that it is all about the oil. Question is, what makes anyone believe Obama will do anything different going forward, since his role is to protect and maintain the status quo just like his predecessor?

 

 

 




Mailbox: E-Mails, Faxes and Telephone Calls



Email www.nj.com...Gov. Chris Christie's deep cuts to state school aid last year left New Jersey's schools unable to provide a "thorough and efficient" education to the state's nearly 1.4 million school children, a Superior Court judge has found. Judge Peter Doyne, who was appointed as special master in the long-running Abbott vs. Burke school funding case, issued an opinion that also found the reductions "fell more heavily upon our high risk districts and the children educated within those districts." "Despite spending levels that meet or exceed virtually every state in the country, and that saw a significant increase in spending levels from 2000 to 2008, our 'at risk' children are now moving further from proficiency," he said. The Abbott vs. Burke case landed back in court after the Education Law Center, a Newark-based school advocacy group, filed a motion charging that Christie's aid cuts violated the state's school funding formula.


Email www.marketwatch.com...Civil War erupts, led by super rich...By Paul B. Farrell...Yes, "there's class warfare, all right," warns Warren Buffett. "But it's my class, the rich class, that's making war, and we're winning." Yes, the rich are making war against us. And yes, they are winning. Why? Because so many are fighting this new American Civil War between the rich and the rest. Not just the 16 new GOP governors in Wisconsin, Michigan, Ohio, Florida, and across America fighting for new powers. Others include: Chamber of Commerce billionaires, Koch brothers, Forbes 400, Karl Rove's American Crossroads, Grover Norquist's Americans for Tax Reform -- which now has 97% of House Republicans and 85% of the GOP Senators signed on his "no new taxes" pledge -- the Tea Party and Reaganomics ideologues. Wake up America. You are under attack. Stop kidding yourself. We are at war. In fact, we have been fighting this Civil War for a generation, since Ronald Reagan was elected in 1981. All this was predicted back in September 2008 by Naomi Klein, author of "Shock Doctrine: The Rise of Disaster Capitalism." Klein warned in September 2008, Reaganomics "ideology will come roaring back when the bailouts are done. The massive debts the public is accumulating to bail out the speculators will then become part of a global budget crisis that will be the rationalization for deep cuts to social programs, and for a renewed push to privatize."

 

Email...www.oregonlive.com...In House food cuts, it's women and children first...By David Sarasohn...The Women, Infants and Children program (WIC) provides support and food vouchers for pregnant women and children in their first four years, and also does health checks and refers kids for medical and other services. WIC's offerings include milk -- whole milk until the second birthday, low-fat afterward -- and fruits and vegetables. In a tough economic time, WIC provides proven health and nutritional benefits to about half the country's infants and their families. Naturally, the new House of Representatives wants to cut it. HR1, the House's proposed budget to get us to Sept. 30, would cut WIC $752 million from last year's level. If funding stays at the House's proposed level for the next year, calculates Zoe Neuberger, senior policy analyst at the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities in Washington, DC, "approximately half a million fewer women and very young children could receive WIC benefits and services" than last year.